City Hall. (Photo Flaura Winston)
Just and Rightful Authority
Every shabbat just after the Torah
service, most Conservative synagogues recite the Prayer for our Country by Rabbi Louis Ginzberg. Part of this prayer has
troubled me since I first encountered it in 1998. I and others were independently
led to "invent" an abridged, but more inclusive version of this prayer, by omitting
three key words.
However, before we discuss my variant we need to know a bit of the history and context for this ancient and familiar prayer.
Why do we pray for our country?
According to Rabbi
Ed Snitkoff, the importance of praying for the welfare of the ruling body was established by the prophet
Jeremiah after the first exile from Jerusalem, in 586 B.C.E. He tells the exiled Jews, "Seek the welfare of the city where I have caused you to be exiled, and pray to God on its behalf, for in its prosperity you shall prosper"
By instructing the Jews to pray for Babylonia, Jeremiah is teaching them to recognize that in exile they were physically, economically, and politically dependent upon Babylonia and the good will of its rulers. The situation of powerlessness and dependence demanded that God be implored to direct the leaders of the country to rule the Jewish population in a just and merciful way.
In Pirkei Avot
Mishna 2, it says "Rabbi Chanina the deputy [High] Priest said, pray for the welfare of the government (lit., monarchy), for if not for its fear, a person would swallow his fellow live."
We are obligated to concern ourselves with the welfare of our country and government. The alternative of government is anarchy, and Rabbi Chanina points out our need to have a government to protect us... against ourselves.
Natural and man-made disasters such as
hurricanes and black-outs give us a brief glimpse into the nightmare of anarchy. Nobody is in control and nobody can stop us -- and both the best and the worst in people are brought out. And while some rise to the occasion to help others in need, others see nothing other than an opportunity to ignore all rules of justice and fair play. Such times test a person's true worth: do I truly fear G-d or do I behave because of the constraints of civilized society? But, advises R. Chanina, let us not wait and see who passes such a test. A civilized and ordered society is the best guarantee we will all live happy and productive lives, so we must pray for its well-being.
The first siddur including a prayer for the government is from the 14th century, and the practice is described there as an "established custom." Hundreds of different prayers for various governments under which Jews have lived (and live) exist today, and are valuable windows to these Jewish communities.
Jews in Diaspora over the last 2000 years have resided in a variety of usually less-than-welcoming host countries. Still we bless them. The
Torah goes so far as to instruct us not to hold an Egyptian in contempt, "for you were resident in his
land." We honor our hosts, we support them, and we "seek their peace."
In much of the Diaspora, Jews prayed specifically for the king, and so did American Jews until the American Revolution when the word "king" was replaced with "president".
Helen and I lived in Bordeaux, France for several years, and I learned that in pre-Revolutionary times Bordeaux's Jewish community did not follow a fixed version of the prayer for the government, but would adapt it each week to the occasion seeking health, victory in battle or successful negotiations for the King. The prayer was transcribed after shabbat in an elegant handwriting and dispatched to Paris so the King would be aware of the Jewish community's good wishes on his behalf.
I grew up reading the Prayer for the Government from the Birnbaum
Ha-Siddur Ha-Shalem and the Artscroll Siddur which is very specific calling for "He who granted victory to kings ... may he bless and protect, help and exalt the president and the vice-president and all the officers of this country" [hanoteyn t'shua lemelachim ... yeverech, v'yishmor v'yintzor v'yazor veromeym vegadeyl venasey l'ma'alah et hanasi v'et mishneyhu v'et kol sarei ha'aretz
In contrast the prayer in Sim Shalom originally composed by Rabbi Louis Ginzberg does not specifically mention any particular government official but rather requests G-d's blessings for "all who exercise just and rightful authority", and goes on to ask that G-d "teach them the insights from [the] Torah, that they may administer all affairs of state fairly".
Who exactly -- if anyone -- are we blessing here?
In other words, does anyone exercise just and rightful authority? For if not, are we not making a
brachah l'vatalah -- a prayer in vain?
So does anyone exercise just and rightful authority? In order to answer that question, we must first consider what do we mean by "just and rightful authority"?
"Rightful authority" means two things. First of all, that the officer holder obtained his office through legitimate means. Clearly, it is not in our power to discern what is going on behind closed doors, and many elections from Lyndon Johnson's election to Congress, Kennedy's defeat of Nixon, Nixon's defeat of McGovern, and Bush's defeat of Gore and then Kerry, were considered illegitimate by many critics.
Secondly, "Rightful authority" means that the office holder is only exercising the authority inherent in his position, and not adopting unconstitutional means to advance his objectives. For example, whether or not one agrees with their goals, many considered the Nixon and Bush wiretaps to be outside the prerogatives of Executive Power vested by the Constitution.
Without having inspected every ballot, and without being a constitutional scholar, and without being privy to every decision made by the President or any other figure in our government, it is impossible for us to divine with 100% confidence whether or not his authority is "rightful".
Similarly, it is difficult to determine if authority is being used "justly". Authority is being used justly, that is, equitably or fairly, when it is being used to advance the well-being of everyone, not just the well-to-do, or the well-connected. In
Parshat Mishpotim we learned
that officials should "take no gift, for the gift blinds the wise, and perverts the words of the righteous". Just as surely as bribes corrupt a judge, political money corrupts politicians whether from a legal PAC or from illegal sources such as those being alleged concerning Abramoff or Delay.
When I say that "just authority" advances the interest of everyone, I mean that it advances the interests not only of our current generation but generations to come. Is it "just" to our children and grandchildren, to cut taxes while fighting a costly war? Is it "just" to our children and grandchildren, to squander our precious resources, ruin our environment, and permanently change our
Only the kadosh baruch hu knows the full consequences of our actions and can say for sure who is "exercising just authority".
Then what should we do if we are not sure those leading the government are exercising "just and rightful authority?"
When I read the prayer for the country, I recite an abridged version, dropping the words "just and rightful". My version is more inclusive, asking for G-d's blessings for all who exercise authority regardless of the nature or source of that authority.
I know several people who stopped reading the prayer for the government following events such as the wars in Vietnam and Iraq which to them were evidence of unjust or wrongful authority.
However, I disagree with such a stand.
Even in Nazi Germany, many Jews continued to recite the prayer for the government, but of course with a somewhat different
kuvunah or intent. They were praying for G-d to grant the government the wisdom to end their persecution of the Jews.
Imagine hypothetically for just a minute that our leader was exercising authority that was not his, and that he was doing so in a callous unjust manner. If that really was the case, then our leader, our government and our country would be all the more in need of being taught insights from G-d's Torah, so that they could once again "administer all affairs of state fairly,
that peace and security, happiness and prosperity, justice and freedom may forever abide in our midst".
Daniel E. Loeb is
the publisher of the Philadelphia Jewish Voice
Dan expressed his concern about a prayer which is not
actually found in our siddur. We pray for Divine support of our leaders and
and advisers and those who exercise just and rightful authority. To wit, we
hope that bureaucrats, policemen and other governmental personnel will be
sustained, as well. I think that we can actually all feel quite comfortable with the prayer as it
-- Mortimer Civan,
I view the clause
"those who exercise just and rightful authority" as
qualifying the first clause "its leader and advisors".
However, I see your interpretation as another valid reading.
Nevertheless, under your interpretation, you are not including for
example the state governor in your prayers unless his gubernatorial
authority is "just and rightful", for the governor is not
the leader of the country (i.e. the president) nor one of his
-- Daniel E. Loeb
The Living Judaism feature in each issue focuses on Jewish spirituality, meaning and activism with invited columns written by rabbis belonging to the various movements of Judaism. Jewish clergy interested in writing for
Living Judaism are invited to make contact with Rabbi Goldie Milgram at
judaism @ pjvoice.com